This Wilderness Our Home

Because sweetness doesn’t have to come at a cost.

We’ve made a lot of caramel in this house—enough that the scent of sugar turning amber feels stitched into our walls. But when John was diagnosed with EOE, butter and cream suddenly disappeared from the pantry list.

He isn’t allergic in the traditional, anaphylactic sense, but over time dairy causes his esophagus to tighten until swallowing becomes difficult. While he might tolerate an occasional small amount, it’s a buildup we’re learning to be careful to avoid. Still, there’s something about caramel—about its warmth and ritual—that neither of us wanted to lose. This recipe was my way of giving that back to him: the familiar glossy spoon-drip, the rich sweetness, and the comfort of not feeling left out.

We’re learning how to rebuild from whole foods, not quick replacements. I won’t touch margarine or ultra-processed dairy “alternatives.” Instead, we’ve been experimenting with ingredients that feel closer to the source—creams and fats that nourish as much as they soothe. This vegan caramel is one of those small victories: safe for him, honest in its ingredients, and still every bit as indulgent.

🍯 A Note on Sweeteners

When I was at Chico State, I took a small cluster of food-studies courses that completely changed how I think about what we eat. One lesson stayed with me: not every ingredient in our food system is there because it’s the best one—it’s often the cheapest or most subsidized.

Corn syrup isn’t inherently bad; it’s the by-product of decades of farm policy that made corn inexpensive and abundant. The result? It slipped quietly into everything—from bread to salad dressing to caramel. The issue isn’t the ingredient itself so much as the system that taught us to rely on it.

That understanding shapes how I cook now. I still love a deep, rich caramel—but I make it with ingredients that feel closer to home, closer to whole, and a little more honest. Small choices, maybe—but they add up to something sweeter in the end.

🍶 Vegan Caramel Sauce Recipe

Ingredients

1 cup granulated sugar

3 Tbsp Miyoko’s Vegan Butter

⅓ cup full-fat coconut cream

3 Tbsp Oatly Barista oat cream (for balance and body)

Pinch fine sea salt

1 tsp pure vanilla extract or vanilla bean paste

Chef’s Tip: Warm your coconut–oat cream blend before adding. The hot caramel will seize less and stay glossy.

Directions (Dry Caramel)

Add sugar to a heavy-bottomed saucepan in an even layer.

Heat over medium, allowing the edges to melt first before gently stirring toward the center.

Continue cooking and swirling until all the sugar liquefies and turns a deep amber. Remove from heat; whisk in Miyoko’s Vegan Butter—it will bubble vigorously. Slowly pour in the warm coconut–oat cream blend while whisking constantly until smooth.

Stir in salt and vanilla.

Cool 10–15 minutes, then pour into a glass jar.

Storage: Refrigerate up to 2 weeks. Warm gently before serving.

This post isn’t sponsored — just something we needed, and maybe you do too. These are the dairy-free staples that made it possible:

Miyoko’s Vegan Butter

Oatly Barista Oat Cream

Related Posts:

Vanilla Bean Caramel Sauce

Chocolate Caramel Sauce

Butterscotch Caramel Sauce

The Cost of Sweetness: A Reflection on Food Systems and Choice – coming soon

This one’s new. We haven’t entirely figured out where it fits yet—can it really replace caramel for us all? We’ll see. But it already feels meaningful, because it’s a step toward something we didn’t want to lose.

We’re learning as we go, reshaping what comfort looks like in our kitchen. Maybe this version will become a new favorite, or maybe it will lead to something better. Either way, it’s a start—a way to keep creating joy within the limits we’ve been given.

Sometimes that’s all we can do: begin again, one small, sweet experiment at a time.

Author’s Note

I’m not an expert in food policy or nutrition—just someone who’s trying to feed her family thoughtfully while learning as she goes. Dairy once filled our table with richness and ease; now we’re finding that same comfort in new forms.

Creating this caramel for John reminded me that nourishment isn’t only about nutrients—it’s about care, creativity, and paying attention. Each substitution we make is a quiet act of love and adaptation, a way to say: we can still have the good things, just differently.